Susana Hands, Your Franchise Specialist

Calling It a Licence Won’t Save You From the Franchising Code

Susana HandsSusana Hands, The Franchise Lady
· 5 min read
Calling It a Licence Won’t Save You From the Franchising Code

If you’re building a network of businesses under your brand, at some point someone, a lawyer, an accountant, or just a nervous business owner is going to ask: “Can we call this a licence instead of a franchise?”

Short answer: you can call it whatever you like. But the law doesn’t care what you call it. It cares what it actually is.

Let me explain this in a plain language

Imagine your mate wants to start a mobile coffee cart using your brand.

Option A: You hand over your coffee blend recipe and the right to use your logo for a flat fee. After that, they’re on their own, their own cart, their own hours, their own supplier, no more calls from you. That’s a licence. You sold them something and walked away.

Option B: You hand over the recipe, but you also tell them exactly what cart to buy, what uniform to wear, what to charge, which supplier to use, and you check in every month to make sure they’re running it your way and they keep paying you a slice of every coffee sold. That’s a franchise. You haven’t just sold a recipe, you’ve sold a whole system, and you’re still steering the ship.

That difference: selling a thing versus selling a system you keep controlling is the whole ballgame.

The actual legal test

In Australia, the Franchising Code of Conduct doesn’t ask what your contract is titled. It asks three questions. Does the agreement give someone the right to run a business supplying goods or services under a system or marketing plan that you substantially determine, control, or suggest? Is that business tied to a trademark, advertising, or commercial symbol that you own, use, license, or specify? And does the other person have to pay you before or during the business for the right to be part of it?

If the answer to those is yes, you’ve got a franchise. It doesn’t matter if the agreement is never called a “franchise agreement”, if it has these defining features, the Code applies anyway.

New Badge, Same Engine

You can peel a Corolla badge off, stick a Ferrari badge on the boot, and call it a Ferrari. It’ll still do 0–100 in the same 9-odd seconds, still need a service every 10,000km, and still can’t merge onto a race track. The badge changed. Nothing else did.

Renaming your operators “licensees” works exactly the same way.

You can call your operators “licensees” if you want to. But if the arrangement has the attributes of a franchise, it IS a franchise and the Franchising Code applies whether you like the label or not.

You don’t get to opt out of the Code by choosing a friendlier word. Regulators and courts look straight past the title of the document to what’s actually happening day to day: who controls the system, who owns the brand, who’s collecting the ongoing payments. The definition looks to substance rather than label, labelling an arrangement a licence, distribution, or agency agreement does not exclude the Code if the substance is a franchise.

This isn’t a theoretical risk. Franchise regulators have taken action against dealer agreements that were labelled as something else entirely and found them to be franchises in substance, and plenty of business owners wrongly assume that calling something a “licence” is enough to dodge franchise regulation, when in practice the substance of the relationship is what counts.

So: if you build a system, control how it’s run, own the brand it operates under, and take an ongoing cut, you’re running a franchise. Full stop. Compliance with the disclosure, cooling-off, and dispute rules isn’t optional just because you didn’t use the word.

The flip side, when “licence” genuinely fits

Not every licence is secretly a franchise. If you’re purely licensing out a trademark or a piece of IP, with no ongoing control over how the business is run and no system being imposed that kind of pure IP licence arrangement is generally treated as separate from a franchise, both in Australia and internationally, though it always comes down to the specific facts and terms of the agreement. A 2021 Federal Court case confirmed this: a licence was found not to be a franchise because the agreement didn’t require the licensee to run their business under a system substantially determined, controlled, or suggested by the licensor that missing control was the deciding factor.

So a genuine, arm’s length licence can exist. But it only survives as a licence if you actually keep your hands off the operational controls. The moment you start dictating branding, processes, pricing, training, or reporting and taking an ongoing fee for the privilege, you’ve crossed the line, whatever the paperwork says.

The safest move if you want to use the word “licensee”

If, for commercial or cultural reasons, you’d rather call your people “licensees” than “franchisees” that’s fine. But do it properly:

  1. Don’t rely on the label to protect you. Assume a regulator, a lawyer, or an aggrieved licensee will read the substance of the deal, not the cover page.
  2. Say it in black and white in your definitions clause. Something like: “References in this agreement to ‘Licensee’ may, depending on the nature of this arrangement, be interpreted as references to a ‘Franchisee’ for the purposes of the Franchising Code of Conduct.”
  3. If your model crosses the line into franchise territory, control, system, brand, ongoing payment, comply with the Code. Disclosure documents, cooling-off periods, dispute resolution processes, the lot. Calling it a licence buys you nothing if the substance says franchise.

Not sure which one you’ve actually got?

This is exactly the kind of thing worth getting a second opinion on before it becomes a problem. If you want your business properly assessed for whether it’s a good fit to turn into a franchise offer or whether what you’re already running is quietly a franchise in disguise, book a Pick My Brain session. It’s a 45-minute call with Susana Hands for a small fee, followed by a written report covering what was discussed and clear recommendations on where to go from here.

The takeaway

Naming your model is a marketing decision. Whether it’s actually a franchise is a legal fact, decided by what you control and what you take from the relationship, not by what’s printed at the top of the contract.

Badge or no badge, a Corolla is still a Corolla. Call your model whatever you want in your marketing. Just make sure your legal documents are honest about what it really is.

This is general information, not legal advice, anyone building one of these models should get it checked against the current Code by a franchise lawyer before they sign anyone up.

THINKING OF FRANCHISING? Is your business ready to franchise? Answer 10 questions and get your Franchise Readiness Score, your stage and your next step.
Franchise Readiness Score →
Susana Hands, The Franchise Lady
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Susana Hands, The Franchise Lady Franchise consultant and franchise sales specialist with more than 15 years as a franchisee, franchisor and consultant, and more than $52.3 million in franchise sales. Author of The Optimal Franchise System and host of Let’s Talk Franchising. More about Susana →
keep reading

More franchise advice

All articles →
once a month

Get new articles and episodes in your inbox

Susana Hands on the phone taking notes at her desk